2024 NCAA Tournament Bracket Watch: UConn No. 1 overall, and then chaos

(Editor’s note: This is part of the Bracket Central Series, an inside look at the run-up to the men’s and women’s NCAA Tournaments, along with analysis and picks during the tournaments.)

During the season in this space, we often like to begin with a bit of pop culture or history or some other random bit of nonsense unrelated to college basketball. So, uh, is it OK if we just do that for the entirety of this final installment?

Because we’re going to be totally transparent here. For the first time in six years of making mock brackets for The Athletic, we go into Selection Sunday with no earthly idea of what the selection committee is going to do. Oh, sure, there are always small surprises, but for the most part, the field is obvious except for maybe one slot.

Not this year. After one of the wildest Championship Week Saturdays we can remember, which included two power-conference bid thieves and a still-hard-to-believe outcome in the American, we find ourselves utterly confused by the bubble. And whether North Carolina will hold on to that final No. 1 seed or if surging Iowa State will take it. At least we’re not alone:

Been doing this since 2006. It’s never been this hard for the committee, not only because of how close so many of these teams are, but because of the abundance of bid thieves which have knocked teams out. Going on midnight but the work continues. That’s why they call it Madness.

— David Worlock (@DavidWorlock) March 17, 2024

Here goes our best shot:

• NC State and Oregon winning their way into the field means that Virginia and Oklahoma are out.

It’s not so simple that the committee simply will replace UVa with the Wolfpack in an ACC tradeoff. Virginia was our last at-large on Saturday morning, and the Cavaliers did lose head-to-head to NC State on Friday, so it seems fair that they’re the first ones to get the boot. We then considered a de facto Pac-12 switcheroo of Oregon and Colorado, since the Buffaloes made our field for the first time after winning in the Pac-12 semis on Friday.

But all this chaos forced us to dive deep into the resumes again, and … what’s impressive about the Sooners? No bad losses, sure, but they’re 4-12 in Quad 1 and 3-6 on the road. They beat Iowa State and BYU, but both were at home. And beyond that, there’s not a single win against a team in the field. And then there’s the matter of the No. 271 nonconference SOS. Add up the lack of wins, bad schedule, poor road performance and a No. 44 KenPom ranking, and this suddenly doesn’t look like a NCAA Tournament team. Especially as the ninth team out of the Big 12.

• OK, well, who does go to the First Four? Well, if you ever wanted to attend the games in Dayton, get tickets this year. We’ve got Colorado and St. John’s in one play-in game, and the other is … wait for it … Michigan State-Florida Atlantic. That’s right, two teams that started the season in the top 10. But the Spartans, despite their oddly glimmering metrics, are just 19-14 overall, 3-9 in Q1 and 9-14 in the first two quads. FAU, meanwhile, lost a Q3 game to Temple in the AAC semis; the Owls also have two Q4 losses and just two Q1 wins (good ones, though, over Arizona and Texas A&M). If we didn’t know what Florida Atlantic did last year and saw this resume coming out of the AAC, we probably wouldn’t blink an eye at this being a First Four team. And in another oddity, the First Four teams are No. 10 seeds.

• That means Indiana State, Seton Hall, Providence and Pitt, along with Virginia and Oklahoma, are out of our field. All those teams are good enough to win a first-round game. Some, more than that. Greg Sankey will be furious Sunday night!

• As for the top of the bracket, we’re sticking with UNC. Iowa State looked mighty impressive this weekend, but remember two things: The Cyclones were on the No. 3 line and No. 11 overall in the committee’s top-16 reveal exactly one month ago. North Carolina was No. 5 overall. It would be a pretty big jump for Iowa State to leapfrog UNC (and the Tar Heels still own the head-to-head with the other contender, Tennessee). Ultimately, it comes down to this: the Cyclones’ No. 324 nonconference SOS. No. 1 seeds simply don’t have schedules that weak, and by putting Iowa State on the 1-line, the committee could set a dangerous precedent we believe it would like to avoid.

There. Disagree, laugh, come back after the bracket reveal to make fun of how wrong we were. Just remember, even the committee knows this Gordian Knot has no real solution. Oh, do you know the Greek legend of the Gordian Knot … well, we had to try to delay some more.

This bracket will be updated shortly before the 6 p.m. ET selection show with final tweaks and automatic qualifiers. Just don’t expect it to make any more sense.

The Bracket Central series is part of a partnership with E*TRADE.

The Athletic maintains full editorial independence. Partners have no control over or input into the reporting or editing process and do not review stories before publication.

(Photo of Tristen Newton: Sarah Stier / Getty Images)