Judge puts brakes on new law banning foreign government spending on referendums


Share post:

PORTLAND, Maine — A federal judge is delaying the implementation of a voter-approved law in Maine that aimed to close an election law loophole by stopping foreign government spending on state referendum races.

U.S. District Judge Nancy Torresen issued a preliminary injunction on Thursday, the day before the new law was to go into effect, after lawsuits by Maine’s two largest electric utilities and organizations representing newspapers and broadcasters. Torresen concluded there was enough merit in their arguments to delay the law until litigation is completed in federal court.

Federal law already bans foreign influence in candidate elections, but many Maine voters were irked over $22 million spent by a Canadian utility to fight state referendums on a hydropower transmission project. Mainers voted overwhelmingly in November to close the loophole and ban foreign governments, or companies with 5% or more foreign government ownership, from donating to future referendums.

The plaintiffs sued on constitutional grounds. The media outlets contended the law requires them to police advertisements and “substantially burdens core political speech and the freedom of the press.”

But the judge focused her decision on arguments brought by the utilities, both of which have foreign ownership.

Versant’s owner is ENMAX, which is owned by the city of Calgary, in Alberta, Canada. Central Maine Power, meanwhile, is a subsidiary of a privately owned Spanish utility, Iberdrola, but minority shareholders include two foreign governments, Norway’s central bank Norges Bank and the government-owned Qatar Investment Authority.

In her decision, Torresen wrote that the 5% foreign-ownership trigger in the law appeared to be arbitrary, though the state pointed out that the figure is borrowed from federal requirements for special disclosures in publicly traded companies.

She suggested the figure was unlikely to survive the U.S. Supreme Court’s ruling in Citizens United that corporations have a First Amendment right to engage in political speech, which includes some campaign-related spending.

“I agree that a 5% foreign ownership threshold would prohibit a substantial amount of protected speech,” the judge wrote.

Source link

Lisa Holden
Lisa Holden
Lisa Holden is a news writer for LinkDaddy News. She writes health, sport, tech, and more. Some of her favorite topics include the latest trends in fitness and wellness, the best ways to use technology to improve your life, and the latest developments in medical research.

Recent posts

Related articles

Stock market today: Asian stocks track Wall Street gains ahead of earnings reports

HONG KONG -- Asian share benchmarks were mostly higher Tuesday after U.S. stocks clawed back a chunk...

Facing pressure from rights groups, World Bank suspends funding for Tanzania tourism project

KAMPALA, Uganda -- The World Bank has suspended funding for a tourism project in Tanzania that caused...

Starbucks takes on the federal labor agency before the US Supreme Court

After Starbucks fired seven workers who were trying to unionize their Tennessee store, a U.S. government agency...

America’s child care crisis is holding back moms without college degrees

AUBURN, Wash. -- After a series of lower-paying jobs, Nicole Slemp finally landed one she loved. She...

Elon Musk accuses Australia of censorship after court bans violent video

MELBOURNE, Australia -- Tech billionaire Elon Musk accused Australia of censorship after an Australian judge ruled that...

Tensions between Beijing and Washington are the biggest worry for US companies in China, report says

Simmering tensions between Beijing and Washington remain the top worry for American companies operating in China, according...

Federal Trade Commission sues to block Tapestry's $8.5B acquisition of Capri

NEW YORK -- The Federal Trade Commission sued to block Tapestry, Inc.’s $8.5 billion acquisition of Capri...

Jury: BNSF Railway contributed to 2 deaths in Montana town where asbestos sickened thousands

HELENA, Mont. -- A federal jury on Monday said BNSF Railway contributed to the deaths of two...