‘For You’ feeds fail on election night, offering outdated information, angering users

Date:

Share post:


“For You” algorithms that promote the most interesting content across a social network, personalized to the individual user, offered a disjointed, outdated, and nearly unusable experience on election night in the U.S. as they highlighted hours-old posts that no longer reflected the current state of the race. Frustrations were particularly high on Threads, Meta’s X rival, where many users complained about seeing hopeful posts about a Kamala Harris win, and those urging voters to “stay in line” or touting early results as a “red mirage,” even after it was clear that Harris was losing ground to President-elect Trump in battleground states. Those posts continued to appear after a Trump victory was nearly realized, as if users had temporarily time-traveled to the past.

“This app is awful for tonight. The outdated garbage I’m seeing in the For You feed is infuriating,” wrote one Threads user, echoing a sentiment shared across the platform on election night.

“Seeing 24 hour old optimistic posts interspersed with the dread of now kind of sucks,” wrote another, speaking to the experience of Harris supporters on the social network, as the feed randomly threw in current posts amid those from earlier in the evening.

Others referred to Threads’ For You feed as rubbing salt in the wound, painful, annoying, and giving off a “non-linear horror movie vibe.“

These complaints aren’t new — but they are indicative of a larger problem facing Threads: its user interface.

As it turns out, the reverse chronological feed these users wanted on Threads already exists.

Launched in July 2023, Threads offers users a Following feed that shows posts only from those users you follow on the social network, without any recommended content included. The feed works similarly to X’s Following feed, in that the posts are not algorithmically sorted, but display in the order they arrive. However, unlike X, the Following feed is fairly hidden in the Threads app — and clearly many don’t know it exists or how to access it.

Meanwhile, on X, moving to the chronological feed is as simple as tapping the tab at the top of the screen, making it easy to switch between a real-time experience and an algorithmic one.

At issue is how Threads has designed its app to hide the Following feed from users.

On mobile, users have to tap the Threads icon at the top of the screen to display the two tab options, For You and Following. Ideally, both tabs would always be available, allowing users to choose which experience they preferred at the time. On the web, meanwhile, Threads has offered a TweetDeck-like experience since May, allowing users to pin multiple columns, including the chronological feed. But real-time events like elections are often watched phone-in-hand while glued to a TV. And it’s here on mobile that Threads falls short.

The problem is not limited to Threads. On TikTok, launching the For You feed on Wednesday morning may display a mix of videos with outdated election coverage personalized to your interests and leanings. (Unless you actively avoided politics on the platform, of course.) That means you could see videos urging voting even after the election has been decided, which is also frustrating and unhelpful.

Whether user complaints will have any impact is unclear, though not very likely.

Regulators have been pushing social media platforms to turn off addictive, algorithmic feeds in some markets, including the EU, but there are no rules in the U.S. about how these feeds need to function or if they can be set as a default. Allowing users to switch permanently to a chronological timeline isn’t an option Meta or others would want because algorithmic feeds work better for advertisers and data indicates they increase user engagement. That leaves users at the mercy of the chaotic algorithmic feeds at a time when real-time information is critical.



Source link

Lisa Holden
Lisa Holden
Lisa Holden is a news writer for LinkDaddy News. She writes health, sport, tech, and more. Some of her favorite topics include the latest trends in fitness and wellness, the best ways to use technology to improve your life, and the latest developments in medical research.

Recent posts

Related articles

Ford will pay up to $165M fine for rearview camera recall failures

Ford has agreed to pay a $165 million penalty to federal regulators after moving too slowly to...

Will Rivian be Volkswagen’s software savior? VW is betting $5.8B it will

Welcome back to TechCrunch Mobility — your central hub for news and insights on the future of...

ChatGPT can now read some of your Mac’s desktop apps

OpenAI’s ChatGPT is starting to work with other apps on your computer. On Thursday, the startup announced the...

New Apple security feature reboots iPhones after 3 days, researchers confirm

Apple’s new iPhone software comes with a novel security feature that reboots the phone if it’s not...

AI pioneer Francois Chollet leaves Google

Francois Chollet, a leading figure in the AI world, is leaving Google after close to a decade....

Amazon’s telehealth platform adds low-cost plans for hair loss, skin care, and more

Amazon One Medical is expanding its telehealth services with the launch of upfront and low-cost treatment plans...

Sales tax automation startup Kintsugi doubled its valuation this year

A 2018 Supreme Court ruling eliminated the requirement that an e-commerce retailer needed a physical location in...

Snapchat will soon be able to alert parents when their teen leaves or arrives at certain locations

Snapchat is bringing enhanced location sharing to Family Center, its parental controls hub, the company announced Thursday. Users...