Judge denies teams' request to sign modified charter agreements in NASCAR antitrust case

Date:

Share post:


The judge in the NASCAR antitrust case denied a request for a preliminary injunction from two race teams on Friday, including the one co-owned by Michael Jordan.

23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports went to court on Monday and argued in favor of the preliminary injunction, which would have granted them the right to sign NASCAR’s 2025 charter agreements, minus a clause that prevents them from taking legal action against NASCAR. The request is part of a larger antitrust lawsuit the two teams have filed against NASCAR and NASCAR CEO Jim France.

But U.S. District Court Judge Frank Whitney ruled the teams did not meet the standard for such a request because they did not prove there would be irreparable harm in the event an injunction was not granted.

“Although Plaintiffs allege they are on the brink of irreparable harm, the 2025 racing season is months away — the stock cars remain in the garage,” Whitney wrote. “… At this stage, the teams are no closer to irreparable harm than they are to the command, ‘Drivers, start your engines,’ at the first race of the 2025 season.”

The teams argued the lack of charter agreements would leave them with the potential loss of their drivers, sponsors, purse money and goodwill from fans. But Whitney ruled that was a “speculative, possible” loss rather than a certain one.

“Plaintiffs have not alleged that their business cannot survive without a preliminary injunction,” Whitney wrote. “Instead, they allege that their businesses may not survive without a preliminary injunction.”

The dispute centers around an extension to the charter agreement 13 of 15 Cup Series teams signed in September, with 23XI and Front Row the lone holdouts.

NASCAR’s charter agreement, comparable to a franchise-like system in place in stick-and-ball sports, guarantees teams a percentage of revenue NASCAR earns through a seven-year media rights deal the sanctioning body signed last year with Fox Sports, NBC Sports, Amazon Prime and Warner Bros. The deal goes into effect in 2025. That percentage is close to 50 percent, according to court documents, making the teams the largest beneficiary of the deal.

23XI and Front Row declined to sign the deal after NASCAR imposed a “take-it-or-leave-it” final offer. The teams later filed a joint antitrust lawsuit alleging NASCAR and France “have used anti-competitive practices to prevent fair competition in the sport.”

NASCAR president Steve Phelps declined to answer questions Friday regarding the lawsuit during his annual “State of the Sport” address, but in a statement emphasized that the teams’ financial wellbeing is important to the sanctioning body.

“We are very happy that 32 of 36 charters were extended,” Phelps said. “And we are excited about that because those race teams — the deal that was put on the table for them, which primarily the big win for the race teams was money. And I won’t go into what that money split looks like, but what I will say is that amount of money, it now puts the race team starting in ‘25 as the single largest beneficiary of our media deal. And we did that because the race teams were upside down financially.”

The Athletic has reached out to 23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports for comment.

(Photo: Jared C. Tilton / Getty Images)

Required reading



Source link

Alexandra Williams
Alexandra Williams
Alexandra Williams is a writer and editor. Angeles. She writes about politics, art, and culture for LinkDaddy News.

Recent posts

Related articles

Submit your questions for Jordan Bianchi's end-of-season NASCAR mailbag

It’s been an eventual and noteworthy 2024 NASCAR season, both on and off the track. Over 38...

2024 Heisman Trophy odds: Travis Hunter takes control heading into final stretch

It’s hard to overcome the quarterback advantage in the Heisman race. Quarterbacks touch the ball on every...

Louisiana governor defends decision to have live tiger at LSU's loss to Alabama: 'Was the only tiger who showed up'

Louisiana Gov. Jeff Landry defended his controversial decision to bring a live tiger back on LSU’s sidelines...

2024 NFL MVP odds: Where Lamar Jackson, Patrick Mahomes and Josh Allen stand after Week 10

A superstar performance from Lamar Jackson during a gutsy Baltimore Ravens’ Week 10 win has the reigning...

Turkish club defend ex-president sentenced to jail after punching referee

Turkish football club MKE Ankaragucu have defended their former president Faruk Koca as being the “target of...

Bucks after 10 games: What's gone wrong early, and do they have time to fix it?

Bucks training camp seems like it was a lifetime ago, Eric.Remember when you and I were down...

Fantasy football Week 11 drops: Xavier Worthy unworthy of rostering. Cut Jonathon Brooks

The fantasy season is about to get real.Week 11 brings the beginning of the stretch run in...

Scouting notes on Cesar Prieto, Johnny Cueto and others from the LIDOM game at Citi Field

A few weeks ago, I saw that the two teams in LIDOM (the Dominican Winter League) with...