Ukrainian commander says he'd be dead if he fought exactly how the US and its allies taught him


Share post:

ukraine training

Ukrainian soldiers receive training from Norwegian instructors as part of a NATO program in August 2023 in Trondheim, Norway.Jonathan Nackstrand /AFP via Getty Images

  • Tens of thousands of Ukrainian soldiers have received NATO training to help them face Russia.

  • But some have said that the lessons do not work well in practice, and have ignored them.

  • One commander told the Financial Times that if he followed NATO advice to the letter, he’d be dead.

A Ukrainian commander trained by US, British, and Polish soldiers told the Financial Times that if he followed their advice exactly he would be killed.

Western allies of Ukraine have offered training to thousands of troops in the hope of steeling them for battle against Russia’s invasion force.

But some have said that the principles they learn from NATO countries often do not pan out on the battlefield.

“If I only did what [western militaries] taught me, I’d be dead,” said a special-forces commander in Ukraine’s 78th regiment who spoke to the FT. The outlet didn’t give his full name, referring to him as Suleman.

During his training, Suleman said he was offered “some good advice” but also “bad advice … like their way of clearing trenches. I told them: ‘Guys, this is going to get us killed.'”

He isn’t the only Ukrainian soldier who has spoken out against the Western approach to instruction.

A senior intelligence sergeant in the 41st Mechanized Brigade, who goes by the name “Dutchman,” told openDemocracy last month: “I don’t want to say anything against our partners, but they don’t quite understand our situation and how we are fighting.”

The soldiers believe that instructors have never fought a war like Russia’s invasion of Ukraine — the first clash of two heavily-armed militaries for decades.

Most Western forces have experience of very different conflicts, like those in Iraq and Afghanistan where their side had huge advantages in resources and far superior technology.

“We need people to understand how to effectively clear trenches, enter them, how to throw grenades effectively, how not to trip on booby traps, to understand what grenades the [Russians] throw — essentially to understand the enemy,” Dutchman told openDemocracy.

In some cases, Ukrainian soldiers have decided to ditch their training completely because it proved ineffective on during their slow-moving counteroffensive, The New York Times reported earlier this year.

A report published by the UK-based Royal United Services Institute (RUSI) earlier this month argued that Western nations should stop training Ukrainians to become NATO-style officers.

Drills should focus on the conditions on the battlefield Ukrainians are fighting on, RUSI warned, instead of NATO-standard norms because it could increase the risk of things going wrong during live operations.

NATO forces also train Ukrainian soldiers to overwhelm their enemies with the type of firepower that it does not possess.

About 63,000 Ukrainian troops have been trained in the West as of August, openDemocracy reported.

The 35-day crash course basic soldier training is mostly held in Germany and the UK, an unnamed source involved in the process told the outlet.

Read the original article on Business Insider

Source link

Alexandra Williams
Alexandra Williams
Alexandra Williams is a writer and editor. Angeles. She writes about politics, art, and culture for LinkDaddy News.

Recent posts

Related articles

Disney, DeSantis legal fights ratchet up as company demands documents from Florida governor

ORLANDO, Fla. (AP) — The legal fights between Disney and Gov. Ron DeSantis ratcheted up this week.The...

Trump suggests bizarre plan to keep forests damp to prevent wildfires in California

Donald Trump suggested that California keep its vast forests damp to prevent wildfire.Trump said he would "get...

Human Remains Found Nearly 3 Decades Ago Identified as Man Who Disappeared After Leaving for a Walk

William Benjamin Adams, a 78-year-old New Hampshire man, had been missing since 1991, according to authoritiesRemains discovered...

McCarthy Turns to Democrats to Keep Government Open

As the U.S. once again hurtles toward a possible government shutdown, House Speaker Kevin McCarthy is turning...

Cassidy Hutchinson says Ted Cruz told her not to be a 'tattletale' after she complained to Mark Meadows that Cruz crashed a Trump tarmac...

Cassidy Hutchinson, in her new memoir, recounted her dismay with Ted Cruz over a 2020 incident.Hutchinson carefully...

It sure looks like Vivek Ramaswamy is hiring a seven-day-week nanny. Starting salary: $100,000.

A job ad likely posted by Ramaswamy seeks round-the-clock care for two young boys.The Republican presidential candidate...

Elite Ukrainian commandos on jet skis conducted a daring raid on a Russian electronic warfare station in Crimea, report says

In recent weeks, Ukraine has stepped up its attacks on the Crimean peninsula, striking various bases of...

Experts are witnessing a strange new phenomenon in the demand for electric cars: ‘We call it the ‘Field of Dreams’ moment’

Huge price reductions and copious availability could provide a boost to the electric vehicle market, which has...