Indian court ruling threatens Google’s advertising revenue model


Share post:

The Delhi High Court has ruled that Google’s Ads Programme falls under the purview of the trademarks act, meaning the search giant’s use of trademarks as keywords amounts to “use” under the act, in a major decision that may redefine online advertising’s legal landscape.

The decision (PDF), delivered by a division bench of Justice Vibhu Bakhru and Justice Amit Mahajan last week, observed that Google was an “active participant” in the use of the trademarks of proprietors. Google’s practice of suggesting competitors’ trademarks as keywords to advertisers yielded significant profits for the search giant via keyword sales.

This case was spurred by a complaint from logistics firm DRS, which pointed out that searches for its trademark “Agarwal Packers and Movers” returned competitor websites. DRS alleged that Google’s ad mechanism exploited its trademark to divert users to rival sites.

Upholding the initial order, the division bench directed Google to act on DRS’s grievances and eliminate offending ads. This verdict implies that platforms like Google must introduce novel systems to address such trademark concerns continually.

“One of the worst ways to spend money as a business is to advertise against your own keywords,” said Nithin Kamath, founder and chief executive of trading platform Zerodha, of the ruling in a thread on social media X. “Businesses do this because if they don’t, competitors who advertise for their keywords show up above them in search results. So if you search for Zerodha, an ad from a competitor might show up above the organic search result. Many times these ads can be deceiving as well. This perverse situation was the result of the lack of trademark protection.”

The court’s assertion that Google is not a “passive intermediary” but runs an advertisement business, over which it has “pervasive control,” comes as a significant blow to the tech giant.

“Merely because the said business is run online and is dovetailed with its service as an intermediary, does not entitle Google to the benefit of Section 79(1) of the IT (Information Technology) Act, in so far as the Ads Programme is concerned,” the bench ruled.

While Google argued its position as an intermediary entitled it to ‘safe harbour’, the bench said they found no issue in the prior single judge’s order, which suggested that the “benefit of safe harbour under Section 79(1) of the IT Act would not be available to it” if they were found guilty of trademark infringement.

This decision casts a shadow on the tech giant’s advertising operations in one of its largest markets.

Source link

Lisa Holden
Lisa Holden
Lisa Holden is a news writer for LinkDaddy News. She writes health, sport, tech, and more. Some of her favorite topics include the latest trends in fitness and wellness, the best ways to use technology to improve your life, and the latest developments in medical research.

Recent posts

Related articles

Qobra raises $10.5 million for its real-time sales compensation tool

French startup Qobra has raised a $10.5 million Series A funding round (€10 million) led by Singular...

LinkedIn goes big on new AI tools for learning, recruitment, marketing and sales, powered by OpenAI

LinkedIn — the Microsoft-owned social platform for those networking for work or recruitment — is now 21...

Adapting to a world with higher interest rates — a guide for startups

Mohit Agarwal Contributor Mohit Agarwal is a leader at a global management consulting firm based in New York, where...

Ten Key Labs wants to simplify managing equity for startups

Amar Varma, a three-time entrepreneur and VC, experienced firsthand the challenge of dealing with administering equity stakes...

HCVC is back with a new $75 million deep tech fund

Paris-based VC firm HCVC just announced the final closing of its second fund simply called “Fund II”....

Cloaked manages your logins with proxy emails, phone numbers and a built-in password manager

Boston-based privacy and security startup Cloaked, launched its apps today to let users create unique proxy emails,...

Stitch raises $25M Series A extension led by Ribbit Capital, increasing the round’s total to $46M

Open banking, in which traditional banks release their data via application programming interfaces (APIs) to enable the...

Unitary AI picks up $15M for its multimodal approach to video content moderation

Content moderation continues to be a contentious topic in the world of online media. New regulations and...