“He’s in big trouble”: Experts say Mark Meadows’ “goose is cooked” after new Fani Willis filing


Share post:

Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis fired back at former White House chief of staff Mark Meadows on Thursday after a judge questioned whether his case should be moved to federal court.

Meadows, who was charged alongside former President Donald Trump and 17 others in Willis’ sprawling racketeering indictment, is seeking to remove his state charges to federal court, arguing that his charged conduct fell under his official federal duties as chief of staff and seeking to dismiss the charges. U.S. District Judge Steve Jones, an Obama appointee overseeing Meadows’ request, asked both parties to submit arguments on whether a single overt act out of dozens cited in the indictment is enough to require removal of the charges to federal court.

Willis’ team in a filing on Thursday argued that Meadows’ alleged actions were part of a greater sweeping scheme to aid Trump’s post-election crusade and that even one official should not be enough to boot his case to federal court.

“The circumstances of this case are easily distinguishable,” prosecutors wrote. “The defendant conspired not for any purpose related to his duties as chief of staff, but to transform Mr. Trump from a losing political candidate into a winning one, no matter what the outcome of the election had actually been.”

“Here’s the crux of the argument from the Fulton County DA opposing Meadow’s motion to remove to federal court,” explained Georgia State University Law Prof. Anthony Michael Kreis. “Even if some of Meadows’ acts fell within his duties, he’s not being charged for them. He’s being charged for joining in an unlawful enterprise to overturn the election.”

Meadows’ attorneys in a response argued that Willis’ argument was not enough to prevent the state from being transferred to federal court.

“Removal is also required, even if the State has charged some acts beyond Mr. Meadows’s official duties, because what controls is Mr. Meadows’s articulation of his federal defense, not the State’s articulation of its state charges,” Meadows’ attorneys wrote.

Jones has not said when he plans to rule but has said that the case could set a precedent. At least four other defendants — former Justice Department official Jeffrey Clark, former Georgia GOP Chair David Shafer, state Sen. Shawn Still, and former Coffee County GOP chair Cathy Latham — are also seeking to remove their charges to federal court, where they could potentially draw a more favorable jury pool and perhaps a judge appointed by Trump.

Kreis tweeted that he had been unsure on whether Meadows’ move would work but after Thursday’s filings said he is “confident Willis has the strongest legal argument. Anything is possible but I would be shocked if any pending motion for removal is granted.”

“Mark Meadows’ goose is cooked on federal removal— and so is every other defendant. If you’re Jeff Clark, Shawn Still, Kathy Latham, or David Shafer you’re in trouble. Testifying opens you to cross with little hope. But not taking the stand gets you absolutely nowhere,” he wrote.

Want a daily wrap-up of all the news and commentary Salon has to offer? Subscribe to our morning newsletter, Crash Course.

“Meadows is in big trouble,” agreed Lee Kovarsky, a law professor and expert on the removal statute at the University of Texas, arguing that Willis’ argument is “MUCH stronger.”

To get removal, a federal officer must show that the indicted conduct is both under the auspices of his official duties and “a colorable federal defense,” meaning it can defeat the charge. But Meadows “made no arguments” on the second point, he explained, calling it a “catastrophic blunder.”

Though Meadows argues that the Constitution’s Supremacy Clause gives him immunity from state charges, the Supremacy Clause “can’t be a complete defense to a RICO charge here even if it knocked out *all* overt acts — let alone something less than all of them.”

“A defense is not ‘colorable’ unless it is capable of defeating the count. And on this argument, it’s not just that Willis ‘gets the better of it.’ Meadows lawyers didn’t even get to it,” he concluded. “He’s in big trouble.”

Read more

about Mark Meadows

Source link

Alexandra Williams
Alexandra Williams
Alexandra Williams is a writer and editor. Angeles. She writes about politics, art, and culture for LinkDaddy News.

Recent posts

Related articles

Trump suggests bizarre plan to keep forests damp to prevent wildfires in California

Donald Trump suggested that California keep its vast forests damp to prevent wildfire.Trump said he would "get...

Human Remains Found Nearly 3 Decades Ago Identified as Man Who Disappeared After Leaving for a Walk

William Benjamin Adams, a 78-year-old New Hampshire man, had been missing since 1991, according to authoritiesRemains discovered...

McCarthy Turns to Democrats to Keep Government Open

As the U.S. once again hurtles toward a possible government shutdown, House Speaker Kevin McCarthy is turning...

Cassidy Hutchinson says Ted Cruz told her not to be a 'tattletale' after she complained to Mark Meadows that Cruz crashed a Trump tarmac...

Cassidy Hutchinson, in her new memoir, recounted her dismay with Ted Cruz over a 2020 incident.Hutchinson carefully...

It sure looks like Vivek Ramaswamy is hiring a seven-day-week nanny. Starting salary: $100,000.

A job ad likely posted by Ramaswamy seeks round-the-clock care for two young boys.The Republican presidential candidate...

Elite Ukrainian commandos on jet skis conducted a daring raid on a Russian electronic warfare station in Crimea, report says

In recent weeks, Ukraine has stepped up its attacks on the Crimean peninsula, striking various bases of...

Experts are witnessing a strange new phenomenon in the demand for electric cars: ‘We call it the ‘Field of Dreams’ moment’

Huge price reductions and copious availability could provide a boost to the electric vehicle market, which has...

A democratic nation has been allowed to die – the UN has failed once more

It happened quickly, the final invasion, and with hundreds of Orthodox Christians killed by the aggressors. Armenia,...